Faux PotsThe New Planters

Is the pot real or fake?Containers are an easy and effective means of introducing seasonal color on a front porch or back terrace in spring or summer, or even to provide interest in the winter landscape. But large ornamental terra cotta or stone planters are expensive, may not hold up well in our severe winters and are difficult to move to a sheltered spot to protect against winter damage. Or are they? 

Real or faux terra cotta?Modern technology now brings us new plastic pots that mimic their heavier and more expensive originals. Don't cringe at the word plastic – the new generation of planters are virtually indistinguishable from the real thing. Lightweight and tough, in a variety of textures, materials, colors and styles, and often beautifully detailed, these planters are a terrific alternative to containers made of traditional materials. 

These plastic pots are much easier to move than real ones made of terra cotta.These lightweight new pots have the look of terra cotta, cement, or stone, but with the durability of synthetics. Many of the original look-alikes were poor imitations of terra cotta that didn't look very convincing and crumbled after a few years of hot sun and cold winters. But manufacturers are now combining classic Italian designs with modern materials to produce pots with many of the advantages of terra cotta, but without the disadvantages. Many of the fakes look just like the real thing – you'd never know they're not made of clay or stone until you lift them. 

These new types of pots are weather resistant.Planters made with newer materials can be deceptively light yet are resistant to cracking, chipping, and breaking in freezing weather. Their light weight makes them easier to move. Most are 80-90% lighter than clay or stone. This means you can have a very large planter (some are offered in sizes up to 52 inches in diameter) and still be able to move it without hurting your back (at least when empty: use caution when lifting any containers filled with soil and plants – even in light weight containers they still can present a challenge to move by yourself).

A white bird of paradise planted in a large, lightweight pot.These pots are also great for indoor use. I have a 6-foot tall Strelizia alba (white bird of paradise) in my greenhouse that I could barely move (much less lift) that was bursting out of its plastic pot, but I couldn't find anything bigger among the typical houseplant containers. It's now happily living in a much larger, grapevine-design faux weathered terra cotta pot. To reduce the weight further, I used styrofoam peanuts for a drainage space in the bottom of the container rather than pot shards or gravel, and used a fair amount of peat rather than soil in the potting mix. Even with all that, the whole thing is relatively heavy, so I placed the container on heavy duty rollers to make moving it even easier.

The most widely sold synthetic containers are made from polyurethane or polyethylene. It's easy to determine which is which:

 Polyurethane is up to an inch thick and has the feel of hardened styrene foam. It is a good insulator that will keep plant roots from overheating in summer and help extend the season in fall. Most pots are guaranteed for at least 36 months against chipping, cracking, fading and freeze damage. They can by easily drilled for drainage, if they don't already have a drainage hole in the bottom. The walls of polyurethane pots are about an inch thick and look like hardened foam.
 Polyethylene may appear indistinguishable from terra-cotta on the outside, but the rim is rolled over to the inside to make it appear as thick as terra cotta. The rest of the pot wall is only 1/4 to 3/8 inch thick. Despite its thinness (which makes it lightweight) the material is tough, resisting damage from sun and frost. Although this type of pot is good-looking, it doesn't have the insulating capacity of the polyurethane pots. These normally have pre-drilled holes. Polyethylene pots have a rolled edge to make the pot appear as thick as terra cotta or stone, but the walls are actually very thin.

Many garden centers and discount stores offer a variety of large, lightweight pots.Regardless of the material, these pots come in a variety of colors and textures, some that mimic granite or sandstone, as well as the typical terra cotta. And the cost of these larger faux pots is much less than the real thing. In one store I visited the 20" imitation terra cotta pots were only about $25, while similar sized ceramic or stone planters were priced around $75. 

Several brands are manufactured in the U.S. (such as Terra Lite™, Thermo-Lite® or Planterra) and others are imported from Italy or other countries. They are widely available in garden centers and nurseries (and of course you can find many for sale on the Internet), and many of the discount retailers (e.g. Home Depot, Lowe's, Sam's Club, Target, Wal-Mart) carry a variety of fake terra cotta/stone pots. Each may have a different selection of designs, colors and sizes, however, so you may have to shop around to find exactly what you're looking for.

Susan Mahr, University of Wisconsin - Madison 

Brand names and commercial businesses are listed only for reference. Such references are not intended as an endorsement by the University of Wisconsin - Extension over similar brands or businesses.

Some suppliers of faux pots:

Return to Horticulture Information Page